The baseball world is buzzing with speculation as Zac Gallen's free agency saga continues, leaving fans and analysts alike wondering: Could a reunion with the Arizona Diamondbacks be on the horizon? While it may seem like a long shot given the team's recent efforts to trim their payroll after a record-spending spree in 2025, Gallen himself has expressed a heartfelt desire to return to the place he now calls home. But here's where it gets intriguing: despite a tumultuous 2025 season, Gallen's potential comeback could be a game-changer for the D-backs, both on and off the field.
In a recent interview with Blake Niemann of FOX 10 Phoenix, Gallen opened up about his deep connection to Phoenix, revealing that his wife is from the area and that they've established their home base there. “It’s been really humbling that [fans] have come up to me and would like me to come back,” Gallen shared, his voice filled with emotion. “It gives you chills that people still want you to come back and be a part of the organization.” And this is the part most people miss: even after a disappointing first half of the 2025 season, where Gallen struggled with a 5.60 ERA and a career-high 23 home runs allowed in just 22 starts, the fans' unwavering support has left a lasting impression on the pitcher.
But was Gallen's 2025 season really as disastrous as it seemed? While his initial performance was undeniably rough, a closer look at the numbers reveals a more nuanced story. Although Gallen's strikeout rate dipped slightly during his final 11 starts, his command improved significantly, and he managed to reduce hard contact. However, the real question is: did his late-season turnaround signify a genuine rebound, or was it merely a statistical anomaly? Some analysts argue that Gallen's improved performance was largely due to a decrease in home runs allowed, which can be a volatile metric in smaller sample sizes. So, what do you think – was Gallen's resurgence for real, or just a fleeting moment of brilliance?
As the D-backs ponder their starting rotation options, currently comprised of Merrill Kelly, Ryne Nelson, Eduardo Rodriguez, Brandon Pfaadt, and free agent signee Michael Soroka, it's clear that adding Gallen to the mix would provide a significant boost in both quality and depth. With a largely inexperienced group of depth options, including Yilber Diaz, Kohl Drake, Mitch Bratt, and Cristian Mena, the team is in dire need of a proven veteran presence. And that's where Gallen comes in – even if he doesn't return to his 2019-2024 form (3.29 ERA, 26.6 K%, 7.8 BB%), his addition would still be a substantial upgrade.
But here's the controversial part: should the D-backs take a risk on Gallen, given their recent history with high-profile signings? The Jordan Montgomery deal, which ended in disaster after Montgomery required Tommy John surgery, still looms large in the minds of fans and ownership alike. Yet, Gallen's situation is markedly different – he's a fan favorite with a proven track record in Arizona, and owner Ken Kendrick has openly praised his dedication to the team. So, is it worth revisiting a similar deal structure, perhaps with a more creative financial arrangement, to bring Gallen back into the fold?
As spring training approaches, the pressure is mounting for both Gallen and the D-backs to make a decision. With interest from other teams, including the Orioles, Cubs, Angels, Giants, and Tigers, Gallen's market is heating up. But for a team willing to take a chance on his potential, the current price point could be an absolute steal. And for the D-backs, a reunion with Gallen might just be the feel-good story they need to kickstart their season.
So, what's your take? Should the D-backs bring back Zac Gallen, or is it too much of a risk given their recent history? Do you think Gallen can return to his previous form, or is his best baseball behind him? Let us know in the comments – we want to hear from you!
